FTM Blog Trans history

Robert Eads, the trans man doctors refused to treat

Imagine this: you are fifty years old, living in rural Georgia, it is 1996, and you are told you have ovarian cancer. Now imagine asking doctor after doctor for treatment and being told no, every single time.

That man was Robert Eads. More than a dozen doctors refused to treat him because he was trans, and by the time a hospital finally accepted him, the cancer had already spread. He died in 1999. Almost thirty years later, his story still answers a question that many trans men never think to ask themselves: which parts of my body am I forgetting about?

How can a man get ovarian cancer?

The same way as anyone with ovaries. Robert had started testosterone and had top surgery, and his doctors had told him that he wouldn’t need a hysterectomy or oophorectomy for his transition. So he kept his uterus and ovaries.

Nothing unusual there. Many trans men keep those organs, either by choice or because surgery is out of reach. Testosterone changes a lot, but it does not switch organs off: someone still needs to check them sometimes, and as it turned out, Robert could not find anyone to do that for him.

What did the doctors say?

Almost always, they said no. The number most sources give is “more than a dozen”, and some accounts say as many as two dozen. According to those reports, several doctors were afraid that treating a trans patient would harm their practice.

The Medical College of Georgia accepted him in 1997. The following year, Robert underwent surgery, chemotherapy and radiotherapy. By then it was too late. In 1998 the cancer had already reached his uterus, cervix and other abdominal organs.

Would a doctor have saved him in 1996? No one can say for sure. Ovarian cancer, though, is one of those illnesses where the months make a difference, and Robert spent a whole year searching for someone to treat him.

How did a film crew end up recording his last year?

In 1998, filmmaker Kate Davis followed Robert and those around him. The result was “Southern Comfort”, released in 2001, which tells the story of his final year.

When you hear about a film following a dying man, you might expect sadness. But this one is really about love.

Robert lives surrounded by a chosen family of trans friends and falls in love with Lola, a trans woman. He takes her to what, for both of them, is their first ever prom night. The film closes at the Southern Comfort Conference in Atlanta, a major gathering for transgender people.

Robert makes it there. He speaks in front of around 500 people. It is his last public appearance.

Has anything changed since then?

Yes, bit by bit. But the fear has not gone away.

The 2015 US Transgender Survey is the big American study on trans people’s experiences. According to its findings, one in three respondents who had seen a healthcare provider that year had had at least one negative experience because they were trans. Nearly one in four avoided seeing a healthcare provider they actually needed, fearing how they might be treated.

The number I think about most is that second one. A refusal is loud. Not making an appointment in the first place, quietly, is not, until the day a symptom becomes impossible to ignore.

What would Robert want for you?

No one can speak for him, so here is what his story suggests, along with what we hear from people in the workshop.

If you still have a cervix, cervical screening is for you too. The WPATH Standards of Care, the main international health guidelines for trans people, say that screening should match the organs a person has. The test can be more uncomfortable on testosterone, so tell the person doing it in advance: they can adapt things to help.

If you still have ovaries, learn to recognise the subtle signs. Ovarian cancer tends to speak quietly: persistent bloating, pain in the abdomen or pelvis, feeling full after just a few bites, needing to wee more often. It is easy to blame every change on hormones when you are on testosterone. If something lasts for weeks, have it checked out.

And find your doctor before you actually need one. It is the advice we give most often. Whether NHS or private, look for someone who knows trans patients while you are well. Then make sure they know your history: your hormone levels, surgeries, what you still have and what you do not.

This matters even more after a hysterectomy, when routine checks no longer arrive by themselves. If something goes wrong, you can call someone who knows you, not just a list of strangers.

In his last year, Robert never went anywhere alone. If appointments make you anxious, bring someone with you. The person with you remembers what was said and asks the question you missed.

How do we remember him today?

Robert died on 17 January 1999 in a care home in Toccoa, the town where he was born. The documentary was later turned into a musical, performed off-Broadway at the Public Theater in New York in 2016.

A little bit of his story lives on every time a trans man books a check-up he has been putting off. In 1996 the doctors Robert saw said no. That does not have to be the case now, for your doctors.

Frequently asked questions

Did Robert Eads have a hysterectomy?

No. He had top surgery and was on testosterone, and he had been told he would not need a hysterectomy, so he kept his uterus and ovaries. The cancer started in his ovaries.

Do trans men on testosterone therapy need cervical screening?

If you have a cervix, yes. Being on testosterone does not remove the need for screening. Tell whoever is doing the test that you are on testosterone, so they can make it easier for you.

Where can I watch “Southern Comfort”?

The film was distributed by HBO and released on DVD. Streaming availability depends on your country, so search for “Southern Comfort, Kate Davis, 2001”.

Sources

Toccoa Falls, Georgia. Photo by Ashwin Visvanathan, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons