FTM Blog Trans history

Robert Eads, the trans man doctors refused to treat

Imagine this: you are fifty years old, living in rural Georgia, it is 1996, and you are told you have ovarian cancer. Now imagine asking one doctor after another for treatment, and being told no, every single time.

That man was Robert Eads. More than a dozen doctors refused to treat him because he was trans, and by the time a hospital finally admitted him the cancer had already spread. He died in 1999. Nearly thirty years later, his story still answers a question many trans men never think to ask: which parts of my body am I forgetting?

How can a man have ovarian cancer?

The same way anyone with ovaries can. Robert had started testosterone and had top surgery, and his doctors told him that neither a hysterectomy nor an oophorectomy was necessary for transition. So he kept his uterus and ovaries.

Nothing unusual there. Many trans men keep those organs, whether by choice or because surgery is out of reach. Testosterone changes a lot, but it does not simply “switch off” organs: someone still needs to keep an eye on them, and as it turned out, Robert never managed to find that person.

What did the doctors say?

Almost always no. Most sources report “more than a dozen,” and some accounts go up to two dozen. According to these accounts, a number of doctors feared that treating a trans patient would harm their practice.

The Medical College of Georgia admitted him in 1997. Over the next year Robert went through surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation. It was too late. By 1998, the cancer had already reached his uterus, cervix, and other organs in the abdomen.

Would a doctor in 1996 have saved him? No one can say for sure. But ovarian cancer is one of those diseases where every month can make a difference, and Robert spent a whole year just looking for help.

How did a film crew end up documenting his last year?

In 1998 director Kate Davis followed Robert and the people around him. The result was "Southern Comfort," released in 2001, showing the last year of his life.

From a film about a man who is dying, you would expect only sadness. But this one, above all else, is about love.

Robert is surrounded by a chosen family of trans friends and falls in love with Lola, a trans woman. He takes her to what, for both of them, is the prom they never got to have. The film ends at the Southern Comfort Conference in Atlanta, a large gathering of transgender people.

Robert makes it there. He speaks to about 500 people. It is his last public appearance.

Has anything changed since then?

Yes, little by little. But fear has not disappeared.

The 2015 US Transgender Survey is the major national survey on transgender people. According to its data, one in three people who saw a healthcare provider that year had at least one negative experience because they were trans. Nearly one in four skipped a doctor they needed, out of fear for how they would be treated.

The number I keep thinking about is the second one. A rejection makes noise. An appointment you never schedule is silent, right up until the day when a symptom becomes too strong to ignore.

What would Robert want from you?

No one can speak for him, so here is what his story suggests, along with what we have learned from clients in the workshop.

If you still have a cervix, cervical screening is for you too. The WPATH Standards of Care, the main international guidelines on trans health, say that screening should follow the organs you have. With testosterone, the exam can be more uncomfortable, so let your provider know ahead of time—they can make adjustments.

If you still have ovaries, learn to notice the subtle signs. Ovarian cancer tends to whisper: bloating that does not go away, pain in your belly or pelvis, feeling full after just a few bites, needing to pee more often. On testosterone, it is easy to blame any change on hormones. If something lasts for weeks, get it checked out.

And find your doctor before you really need one. This is the tip we give most often. Whether you go public or private, look for someone who knows trans patients while you are still healthy. Then trust them with your history: your hormone levels, your surgeries, what you still have and what you do not.

This matters even more after a hysterectomy, when routine screenings stop on their own. If something goes wrong, you want to call someone who already knows you, not start cold with a list of strangers.

During his last year, Robert never went anywhere without company. If appointments make you anxious, bring someone along. The person with you may remember what was said, or ask the question you forgot.

How do we remember him today?

Robert died on January 17, 1999, at a nursing home in Toccoa, the town where he was born. The documentary later became a musical, which ran off-Broadway at the Public Theater in New York in 2016.

A little piece of his story lives on every time a trans man makes that checkup he has been putting off. In 1996, the doctors Robert turned to said no. Yours do not have to do the same.

Frequently asked questions

Did Robert Eads have a hysterectomy?

No. He had top surgery and was taking testosterone, and they told him he would not need a hysterectomy, so he kept his uterus and ovaries. His cancer started in his ovaries.

Do trans men on testosterone need cervical screening?

If you have a cervix, yes. Testosterone does not remove the need for screening. Let your provider know you are on testosterone, so they can make it easier.

Where can I watch "Southern Comfort"?

The film was distributed by HBO and released on DVD. Streaming availability changes from country to country, so look for "Southern Comfort, Kate Davis, 2001."

Sources

Toccoa Falls, Georgia. Photo by Ashwin Visvanathan, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons